Rate this paper
  • Currently rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
5.00 / 4
views 922 | downloads 501
Paper Topic:

`What were the main arguments used by those that were opposed to ratifying the 1787 constitution?`

Name

University

Tutor

Course

Date

Title : Arguments Against the 1787 Constitution

All law that governs United States of America was founded in the constitution written in 1787 but put in practice in 1788 . 1787 constitution was to replace Article of confederation which provided structure for new government after USA attained its independence from Great Britain in 1776 after America revolution . Making of constitution played a very important role of filling the gaps which Article of Confederation was not able to address . The principles making the Article of

Confederation was guide by fear of creating a centralized power similar to the model ruling America under Great Britain . Due to this Article of confederation was not able to solve many problems , for example it never gave the congress the power to levy tax but depended solely on states to contribute a share to common treasury which was not sufficient . Efforts to amend the Article of confederation did not bear fruit after Rhode Island decline to give consent to this proposal Article of confederation exhibited a weakness called the Liberum Veto which every state infatuated any propose amendments . Amendments needed to be passed by all thirteen states and major legislations required consent of nine states . These situations exhibited major loophole because amendments could be defeated just by absence of one or two delegate

These are some of the problems which transpired to drafting constitution in 1787 to solve the weakness exhibited by article of confederation Constitution would provide define executive branch with mandate to execute the law and court system mandated to interpretation of the law Initially , the Article of confederation only established parliament being sole organ of the national government . Constitution was to define the three arms of the government and proposed for a central government with variety of enforceable authorities replacing congress as established by the Article of confederation . Ratifying of the proposed constitution started with state of Pennsylvania calling for the first convention for consideration of proposes constitution . At the request of the Constitutional Convention , the Continental Congress submitted the Constitution to the states on September 23 , and on the next day the Pennsylvania legislature , which was in session , called a convention to ratify or reject the new frame of government . Delegates were elected on November 2 , and the ratifying convention held its first sessions at the State House in Philadelphia on November 21 (Pittman para 1 . At this point in time delegate were divided on the basis of accepting or rejecting the draft i .e . federalist and favoring constitution on basis of strong national government and Anti-Federalist people opposed to constitution (http /www .jburgd12 .k12 .il .us /jjhs /Wbt /Foundations /ratify .htm . para 1 )The argument fronted by Anti-Federalists or those oppose to ratification was , The first was the destruction of states that would lead back to a monarchy . Anti-Federalists felt that states should be the primary unit of government , and that the central government should have little authority , which would act through the states to the people (Johnson...

4 pages
28.5 KB
Free sing-up

Not the Essay You're looking for? Get a custom essay (only for $12.99)