Rate this paper
  • Currently rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
3.33 / 3
Paper Topic:

Should the government be allowed to monitor all phone calls and all email to combat terrorism


Shortly after the attack at the World Trade Center in September 11 President George W . Bush empowered the National Security Agency to snoop around the people residing in the United States without any necessity to acquire the court warrants which was usually needed in such state of affairs . According to the reports , the outcome was that the NSA has supervised the international phone calls and electronic mails of all the people residing in USA ADDIN EN .CITE Regan20051

br 1117Tom ReganBush allowed spying on Americans in US after 9 /11Electronic Science MonitorElectronic Science Monitor2005 (Regan , 2005

The goal of the president 's decision is to quickly supervise the phone calls as well as other aspect of communications of those people who resides in US who are thought to have connection with alleged comrades of al Queda and other terrorists . The authorities does not want to risk the probability that important information would be lost if they would first need to ask for warrants before they tap the modes of communication ADDIN EN .CITE Eggen20052 2223Dan EggenBush Authorized Domestic SpyingWashington Post2005 (Eggen , 2005

The congressional sources who are accustomed to the restricted facets of the program did not give any confidential information , however , they pointed out that the legality of Bush 's decision is questionable . There are many sides to this issue . Where there are people who argues that such tactics is necessary to gain the information the administration needs , there are also those who argue that the government did not pay any heed to the people 's right to privacy and thus for them the action of the government should be put into question

The administration justified their actions regarding its decision on warrantless espionage which he calls terrorist surveillance program by claiming that he discussed the matter with his lawyers . He then moved on to argue that a Congressional decree which sanctions his use of a militia on his war against terrorists presented him the legal power to disregard the legal constraints of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act of 1978 . FISA crafted a special court and a process for approving such espionage . It was passed mainly to avoid future administrative extremes of the same kind as performed by the Nixon administration

However , although Bush made it appear that he passed the act for the common good of his subject and of his country , one could still not deny the fact that there are serious loopholes on his statements . First and foremost the Congressional Authorization for Use of Force had specifically allowed authorities to use militias against states associations , or individuals that may have been involved in the attack on the World Trade Center or to avoid any acts of such kind in the future . Obviously , the trouble is that the decree did not state anything concerning the issue of domestic spying . Truth be told , the Congress made it a point to stop suspicionless ' examinations of Americans by...

Not the Essay You're looking for? Get a custom essay (only for $12.99)