`A Peace to End All Peace` by David Fromkin
A Peace to end All Peace : The Treaty of Versailles Recently , historian David Fromkin wrote a book about the Treaty of Versailles , arguing that it was `A Peace to end All Peace ' hence its title . This is so all the Treaty really offered was only an amicable short-term , settlement between the warring powers that placed Germany in a disadvantageous position . Eventually , this resulted to a sentiment of retribution among the Germans , which backed the rise of Hitler and the start of another World War . How was the Treaty of Versailles flawed Below
Recently , historian David Fromkin wrote a book about the Treaty of Versailles , arguing that it was `A Peace to end All Peace ' hence its title . This is so all the Treaty really offered was only an amicable short-term , settlement between the warring powers that placed Germany in a disadvantageous position . Eventually , this resulted to a sentiment of retribution among the Germans , which backed the rise of Hitler and the start of another World War . How was the Treaty of Versailles flawed Below
are several aspects for discussion
First are the military aspects of the treaty . Germany 's army was reduced to 100 ,000 men the army was not allowed tanks . She was not allowed an air force . She was allowed only 6 capital naval ships (Trueman , n .d . However , this happened only in ' a Germany side-stepped ' the rule and signed her soldiers only for a short contract of service (ibid . Once the contract is done , she put the soldiers in reserve , successfully carrying out the term of having no more than 100 ,000 soldiers at any one time , while still having a substantial amount of reserve troops that helped Hitler rise later (ibid . Also , although Germany was not allowed an air force , she trained potential pilots , as well as submariners , abroad (ibid . This did not break the treaty as there were no provisions regarding it in the first place
Second are the financial and territorial aspects of the treaty . Germany was demanded to cede all of its colonies , to pay financial penalties linked to war destruction , and to not unite with Austria all at the same time (Trueman , n .d . The Treaty also provided for the delivery of capital goods and raw materials to the Allies (Sage , 2006 . To the Germans , these terms offered them severe economic restrictions with possibly no chance of rehabilitation . theless , Germany was still the strongest power in Europe economically , so that the unwise thing about Versailles was that it annoyed the Germans yet did not render them too weak to retaliate (Lowe , 1982
Third and most importantly are the political aspects of the treaty Germany was not even included , much more consulted , in its drafting . She was left all alone , with even the membership to the League of Nations banned against her . Most importantly , she was even made to admit full responsibility for starting the war ' - a term explicitly written in Clause 231 of the treaty , the War Guilt Clause (Trueman , n .d . With her admitting full responsibility , she had to pay for reparations , which are well beyond her ability to pay . The Allies literally pushed Germany to the ground when they made her sign a blank cheque for the reparations which the Allies would cash when it suited them (ibid . Again and again , Germany 's opinion was never asked nor even heard of while the treaty was drafted until it was carried out . The most the Allies did was to convince her...
More Essays on peace, treaty, end, Germany, Versailles
- Treaty of Versailles
- Germanys Violation of The Treaty of Versailles: A study of the Relationship Between Germanys Weapons and Her Aggression.
- The Treaty of Versailles, which concluded World War I, is considered by many historians to be a primary cause of World War II. Why? Explain.
- the economic consequences of the peace
- The Failure of the treaty of versailles
- 2 Assess the settlement of Versailles. What were its good points? Bad points? Was the peace too harsh or too conciliatory? Could it have ensured peace in Europe? How might it have been improved?
- Essay requirements
- In what ways did World Warll end the problems of World War l ? How did the versailles treaty help to inflame the situation?
- Western Civilization
- In what ways did World War II end the problems of World War I? How did the Versailles Treaty help to inflame the situation?