Paper Topic:

`Natural Law jurisprudence automatically lends itself to the teleological approach.` Discuss.

Running Head : `Natural Law jurisprudence automatically lends itself to the teleological approach . `

`Natural Law jurisprudence automatically lends itself to the teleological approach . `

Authors Name

Institution Name Natural law has become quite diverse foci for theories concerning human conduct , not only placing diverse requirements on the theorist , but requirements which appear to be at cross purposes . Natural law can be kept for an important , but narrow problem : the enunciation of some basic human goods or needs that any system of positive law should respect promote , or in any

case protect (William Blackstone , 1979

Theorizing concerning natural law and virtue , therefore , can be sharply famed for reasons . On the whole , for the reason of the demise of the older teleological view of nature that allowed theorists like Aquinas to correlate the analogous meanings of law and nature around the matter of natural inclinations . These inclinations , on Aquinas ' view , are the soil for both virtues and the first principle of the natural law . The reason of law as well as the nurturing of the habits takes their bearing from a pre-given teleological

Aquinas comes as near as he ever comes to a of law in the claim that 'Law is nothing else than an ordinance of reason for the common good , made by him who has the care of the community , and promulgated (Thomas Aquinas , 1988 . This general definition is followed by a peculiarity between the three kinds of law--eternal , natural , and human . Now , it might seem that on its own Aquinas 's categorization as applied to the specific case of human law would produce an essentially positivistic view of human law

We can obviously understand God as having care of the ideal community and as propagating ordinances of reason for the common good of that community

We can make sense of the thought (even if we reject it ) that 'Nature likewise works for the 'common good ' of only 'natural ' things , a standard teleological theory of biology might assert something like that . But , it can be said , the obvious way to understand the in the case of human law is in terms of a ruler , or whoever is designated as lawmaker by the rule of respect , promulgating laws in terms of the lawmaker 's discernment of the good of the community

As Aquinas said , Human laws should be proportionate to the common good (Thomas Aquinas , 1988 , Q . 96 A . 1 'Nature ' designates not simply the quiddities of things , the formal cause that which makes a thing what it is but more significantly the finality governing completions . Right reason , on the conventional teleological view of natural law , cannot mean simply judgment agreed with natural values , but judgment in accord with what completes these values . As the older teleological theories allowed natural law analysis to play both roles--to expound the goods embedded in human actions as well as their completions-the modern denunciation of teleological thinking guarantees that a natural law principle of recta ratio should restrict itself to discourse concerning...

7 pages

43.5 KB

Free sing-up