Rate this paper
  • Currently rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
4.75 / 4
Paper Topic:

Critical Review of Scholarly Journal Articles

Critical Review of three Scholarly Journal Articles of Racial Profiling

Your name Here


The purpose of this critique is to look on the facts and findings found by three scholarly journals about racial profiling

Racially Biased Policing : Determinants of Citizen Perceptions (Weitzer Tuch , 2005

Race-Based Policing : A Descriptive Analysis of the Wichita Stop Study (Withrow , 2004

Perceptions of Racial Profiling : Race , class and Personal Experience (Weitzer Tuch , 2002

This document also goes further by validating the data gathering methods and analysis techniques used by the author

to support their findings CRITICAL REVIEW

Racially Biased Policing : Determinants of Citizen Perceptions

One of the most important finding generated by this is the effects of race on the view that police is biased on race . This includes racial profiling of police where Black or minority group in general are most like stopped by police than White American . In all four models , blacks and Hispanics are more likely than whites to believe that police bias is a problem (Weitzer Tuch , 2005 . Blacks however , according to this article perceives police bias more of a problem than Hispanics . One interesting subset of this is that Blacks tend to perceive police discrimination against Hispanics than Hispanics see themselves . So that Black Americans tend to see that Hispanic drivers are being racially prod compared to white drivers . Another important finding presented by this article is the role of media in shaping the perceptions of people regarding racial discrimination . People who frequently hear or read about incidents of police misconduct , as transmitted by the media are inclined to conclude that the police engage in racial profi ling are prejudiced , and discriminate against minority individuals

and neighborhoods (Weitzer Tuchs , 2005

The data gathering method and analysis technique used in this article is solid considering that it is based on a national survey of national survey of 1 ,792 white , African American , and Hispanic adult residents of U .S . metropolitan areas with at least 100 ,000 population (Weitzer Tuch , 2005 . The survey results where advantageous in the sense that oversampling African Americans and Hispanics , in contrast to the small number of minority respondents common to other surveys . Another advantageous factor is the tapping of both attitudes toward police and personal and vicarious experiences with the police . Another very important correction factor they have added is idea that there are differences in the number of households with phone access from the three different races , Black , Hispanics and White American . This is very important consideration since the data was collected using random dialing of phone numbers . So in general the data was very reliable

Race-Based Policing : A Descriptive Analysis of the Wichita Stop Study

Unlike the previous article which discusses racial discrimination of policing in a wider perspective , this article focuses on racial profiling . The results of this rigorous effort put on the analysis of enforcement pattern do not prove race-based policing . The result of this document instead provides guidance for what are needed on studies to determine...

Not the Essay You're looking for? Get a custom essay (only for $12.99)