Critical Evaluation of a Research Article

A Critical Evaluation of the Article : Nonresident Fathers and Children 's Well - Being : A Meta - Analysis For some reason , children who come from broken homes or single parent families are often pitied or worse , stereotyped to be rule-breakers Although this misconception may have a grain of truth to it , it is still unfair for children from single parent families to be thought of this way . However , one cannot attest the importance of having a family that children can always come home to . In the same light , the importance of a father 's

permanence in the family also plays a role in the child 's well-being . This is exactly what the authors , Paul Amato and Joan Gilbreth , tried to establish in the study aptly entitled , Nonresident Father and Chidlren 's Well-Being : A Meta-Analysis . Using meta-analysis non-resident fathers and its effects of their children was studied Non-resident factors may have a number of effects to their children however , the study decided to focus only on children 's well-being based on the fathers ' financial support , frequency of contact between fathers and children , feelings of closeness , and authoritative parenting . The last two factors were found to be positively associated with the children 's performance in school , but are negatively associated with the children 's ability to externalize or internalize problems . The introduction included all the vital elements which readers would like to know about the study , delivered in an appropriate and highly understandable manner . Even readers with no background on research or psychology would immediately understand the study 's purpose and also its implications . The well-chosen words gave a clear notion of the problems the study 's purpose and also its significance . The introduction clearly stated what the study focused on , specifically how non-resident fathers affect their children . A generalized outcome was also included in the study , including the method which the authors utilized through the course of their study

The hypothesis is also clearly stated . The study intended to find out what , aside from monetary assistance , are the contributions non-resident father have on their children . From the main hypothesis , the authors decided to branch out to see specifically how payment of child support frequency or contact , feelings of closeness , and authoritative parenting affect the children 's well-being in general . All these factors have been well considered as evidenced by the different citations seen in the literature review . Indeed , it can be said that the authors have carefully thought of these variables in to make a significant contribution about non-resident fathers and their effects to their children

The literature review is arranged systematically and comprehensively Each variable is well supported by the assumptions and findings of different researchers and their researches made prior to the study . The literature review then provides a firm foundation on which the authors hypotheses and assumptions are founded . One can also see that the authors used sources which are quite current . Reading the literature review would give readers a clear picture of the problem , including the studies made...