Covering law model of explanation
1 . What is the `covering law ' model of explanation Carl Hempel 's covering law ' model of explanation states essentially that an explanation for an event can be drawn from a set of general laws or , in the case of the social sciences , universal hypotheses . Hempel claims the study of history is not generally associated with the search for general laws governing historical events . However , history is a discipline within which the theory of covering law ' - with some slight modifications - can function Hempel 's model is one of deductive reasoning in which
Carl Hempel 's covering law ' model of explanation states essentially that an explanation for an event can be drawn from a set of general laws or , in the case of the social sciences , universal hypotheses . Hempel claims the study of history is not generally associated with the search for general laws governing historical events . However , history is a discipline within which the theory of covering law ' - with some slight modifications - can function
Hempel 's model is one of deductive reasoning in which
two sets of information are paired to develop a hypothesis : one set includes all the facts of an event (time , place , actions , etc ) while the second includes applicable empirical laws (laws governing the variables in situations similar to those in the first set . Hempel claims that the covering law ' is relevant to social sciences because , like in the natural sciences , because both have similar strengths and weaknesses with regard to their ability , or lack of ability , to grasp the unique individuality ' of their objects
Hempel is adamant about the use of empirical laws , and cautions especially in the social sciences , against using romantic ideals such as destiny ' and mission in history ' in place of scientific explanations . To determine the suitability of an explanation , Hempel states that the explanation must satisfactorily pass a series of tests These tests include empirical tests of the sentences which state the determining conditions ' and the universal hypotheses on which the explanation rests ' in addition to an investigation of whether the explanation is logically conclusive in the sense that the sentence describing the events to be explained follows the statements ' of the two sets of information (45
Hempel , Carl . The Function of General Laws in History
2 . Is the model applicable to the study of human phenomena
While Carl Hempel asserts that his covering law ' model of explanation is applicable to social sciences , the reality of this claim is called into question by several other authors
F . A . Hayek 's initial criticism of Hempel 's model is that is can only serve a reactionary function , because it relies on the identification of patterns to initiate inquiry . Thus , predicting outcomes is nearly impossible without first being able to recognize problems and all relevant variables . In the case of history the model might have some limited use , but only when both the causes and effects have already been identified . Even in the case of history then the applicability of the covering law ' model is limited by the mind 's ability to locate patterns
This would not be such an insurmountable challenge if the patterns were themselves easily discernable . Indeed , the principle fault Hayek finds with the covering law ' model is that while it can be applied to social sciences theoretically , it is unable to cope with the complexity of issues and variables inherent in the more complex phenomena of life , mind , and of society ' Hayek determines a patterns level of complexity by seeking the minimum...
More Essays on model, law, covering, Collingwood, Romanos
- The 'new' police model introduced in 1829 has been seen as revolutionary. Analyse its introduction and form, before commenting on how appropriate it remains now for contemporary society.
- Internet contract
- Response to an Economic article.
- REVISION:Formation of contract over Internet under English Law, the
- criminal justice system ( shabah )
- Philosophy of Science
- Policy Analysis
- Making Sense of the Criminal Justice System
- EU Constitutional Law
- Deceitful Scheme